There is no more lead in MY dinnerware… I think…
November 19th, 2007 | by zakary |I have been delaying writing a follow-up post to “I’m sorry, why is there lead in my dinnerware?” for a while, however after hearing last week a very unsettling news report out of Utah, in which a toddler may have suffered lead poisoning in utero and from breast milk due to her mother’s exposure to the lead glaze on their Gibson Overseas dinner plates, it was pretty hard to delay it further.
A few months back I contacted a number of dinnerware manufacturers - Corelle, Dansk, Dudson, Homer Laughlin China Co., Ikea, Lenox, Mikasa, and Pfaltzgraft - to see if any of their dinnerware products were lead-free. Of these eight manufactures two (Mikasa and Dudson) have never replied, perhaps because they didn’t like the question, or worse, they didn’t know the answer.
Luckily six manufacturers were nice enough to provide some information about their products. Below are the important excerpts from their emails:
Corelle
Our specifications are that stoneware products and glazes are made of clay-based materials and glazes used throughout the industry. Decorations, if present, are made from low-lead enamels and fired at temperatures exceeding 1000 degrees F, which binds any heavy metals both physically and chemically so that their release is minimized.
Dansk
All Dansk dinnerware is made Lead Free.
Homer Laughlin China Co
All of our ceramic products meet the requirements of California’s Proposition 65 for lead and cadmium release. We meet the technical requirements to be called lead free and cadmium free. As we are sure you know, there are trace amounts of lead in the atmosphere which make it impossible to be 100% lead free. You can be sure that our products are as free of lead and cadmium as it is scientifically possible to be.
Ikea
The IKEA product range is subjected to comprehensive tests and complies with the strictest applicable laws and safety standards, and we have detailed regulations on the use of chemicals and other substances in the manufacturing process. If one country tightens its rules, we introduce these new regulations on all IKEA markets, whenever possible. The lead and lead compounds are not allowed to be used and the contamination limit value adopted at IKEA is 100 mg lead/kg.Note: We followed up with Ikea to see if they could clarify what their reference of 100 mg lead/kg was all about and although they have not yet responded to us we did find the following at the bottom of one of the pages in their catalog:
All Ikea ceramics for preparing and serving food are lead- and cadmium safe. This means no heavy metals may be transfered from the glaze to the foodstuffs. For products which come into contact with food. Ikea imposes tougher criteria than the law demands. And tests are made regularly.
Lenox
In response to your inquiry regarding the lead content in our products, lead can be found in our tableware, crystal products and hand-painted products.
Pfaltzgraff
It is our Company Policy to use only lead-free glazes, pigments or decals in our porcelain, stoneware, china and earthenware products. We know of no company with a more stringent policy with respect to the use of lead, cadmium and other contaminants than Pfaltzgraff.
So what is a consumer to do? Well, we immediately took Lenox and Corelle off of our shopping list, followed by Homer Laughlin China Co. simply because we were not overly fond of their style. Next we tried to look for Dansk, but unfortunately we could not find any company selling their dinnerware locally. That only left us with: Pfaltzgraff, Ikea, using glass dinnerware or starting the process all over again.
We hesitated for a while between Pfaltzgraff and Ikea. Pfaltzgraff had some nicer looking dishes, but they all seemed to be made in Asia and we were hoping on finding something made a little closer to home. Ikea in turn had not bad looking dishes made in Europe, Asia, etc. but some of the sets didn’t have any cups. In the end we decided that if we were going to buy dinnerware from a-far, we may as well pick the nicest style, and so we are now eating off of brand new white, stoneware Pfaltzgraff dishes.
The problem with being a consumer, is at the end of the day, it all comes down to blind trust. You can be informed and careful until the cows come home, but unless you can take every product that you purchase into a professional lab for testing, on some level you have to believe that these companies - who are often solely accountable to their shareholders - are doing the testing and have the quality control that they claim to. These days, that is more trust than I have… Which is why although there shouldn’t be any lead in our dinnerware, according to its manufacturer, unless we get it tested I will always have a little spec of doubt! Maybe we should have went for glass dinnerware…
Now, what about the glaze in our slow-cooker… is it lead-free?
117 Responses to “There is no more lead in MY dinnerware… I think…”
By Joan Rummell on Nov 20, 2007 | Reply
Thank you for the update. Good luck finding safe dishes to your liking. I have decided to not store any leftovers on the plates in the fridge. Nor will I reheat anything on them just in case.
By zakary on Nov 20, 2007 | Reply
Hello Joan, it sure seems like finding lead-free products comes down to luck! We have been using Pyrex Glassware food containers for storing leftovers and reheating food. They are great and since they are glass, in theory they are inert, though the lids are plastic so it would be wise to not reheat those. The only problem that we have had with them is over time the lids get loose and you can’t buy new lids separately so you have to buy another container. Anchor Hocking also makes glass food containers, that appear to be pretty similar.
By Anne on Nov 20, 2007 | Reply
Well, you decided to throw away your Corelle dinnerware and replaced it. I am wondering seriously if I should be doing the same thing. I’ll analyse this with Dario. However, I am wondering if you know anything about Corningware. I started using this type of plates for microwave use since they’re not plastic-made, but is the glaze lead-free?
By zakary on Nov 20, 2007 | Reply
Hello Anne, we actually used to have Gibson Overseas dinnerware, the same brand that the toddler in Utah may have been poisoned from, though if we did have Corelle dinnerware I’m not sure if we would keep it, we would probably get an Ikea set and call it good.
I’m not sure about Corningware, my mom was also curious about how safe they are, so we are contacting them. We are also contacting Cuisinart to see whether our slow-cooker is safe.
To be continued…
By Anne on Nov 21, 2007 | Reply
Keep us informed please, because we were thinking about buying a slow-cooker, so we might as well buy wise from the start.
By Danielle on Nov 22, 2007 | Reply
Problème de langue! Qu’est-ce que “lead” et qu’est-ce qu’un slow-cooker?
By Anne on Nov 22, 2007 | Reply
Lead, c’est du plomb, et un slow-cooker, c’est une mijoteuse.
By Diana on Nov 23, 2007 | Reply
Thank you so much for your efforts and research!
By Danielle on Nov 24, 2007 | Reply
Merci! En tous cas, c’est en effet très instructif comme article, Sophie!
By sophie on Nov 24, 2007 | Reply
Merci Danielle… Mais celui-ci, il est de Zakary! Je lui ai fait le message, par contre.
By Danielle on Nov 25, 2007 | Reply
Désolée! C’est vrai que j’ai du mal avec les blogs à deux!
By Bea on Dec 24, 2007 | Reply
Wow, was I glad to get this information. You saved me a few hours of online research.
We bought our beautiful Pfaltzgraff “Villa della Luna” dinnerware just before all the lead/China hoopla this fall. Now I feel a little better about using it.
By Andrea on Jan 14, 2008 | Reply
Corelle GLASSWARE is FINE!!! It’s the stoneware that you have to avoid. Check out this link to a lead test of various dinnerware: www.kutv.com/sites/kutv/content/documents/lead-plates-results.pdf
I just read a way to test whether your mugs have lead:
“Microwave test for mugs: Put an empty mug in the microwave, also put in a measuring cup full of water. Run the microwave on full
power for 1 minute. When you take the mug out it should not be hot. It should feel normal. If it is hot, then it has either lead in the
glaze or moisture in the ceramic, which means fine cracks in the glaze. (either are no good). I did this and some of my older mugs
were scorching hot, the newer corelle were cold.”
From http://onibasu.com/archives/am/174030.html
By Andrea on Jan 14, 2008 | Reply
Corelle GLASSWARE is FINE!!! It’s the stoneware that you have to avoid. Check out this link to a lead test of various dinnerware: www.kutv.com/sites/kutv/content/documents/lead-plates-results.pdf
I just read a way to test whether your mugs have lead:
“Microwave test for mugs: Put an empty mug in the microwave, also put in a measuring cup full of water. Run the microwave on full
power for 1 minute. When you take the mug out it should not be hot. It should feel normal. If it is hot, then it has either lead in the
glaze or moisture in the ceramic, which means fine cracks in the glaze. (either are no good). I did this and some of my older mugs
were scorching hot, the newer corelle were cold.”
From http://onibasu.com/archives/am/174030.html
By Andrea on Jan 14, 2008 | Reply
sorry to submit twice–I guess my enter-button finger is too fast..
By Deby on Jan 17, 2008 | Reply
I called …today…
Corelle corning today….
they said all of their products meet FDA guidlines(scary huh) and their products ALL have lead…at*1/10 of 1 part per million*
so you you like a pinch of arsenic in your stew?
What do you think?
Deby
By Adam on Jan 20, 2008 | Reply
It’s good to know IKEA Dinnerware is lead safe. I wonder how much lead is in their flower pot glazes. I’m looking for a crock of some sort to make sauerkraut in, and it’s very hard to find something big enough that isn’t plastic or metal.
By Rita on Jan 20, 2008 | Reply
Thanks for doing this research–it’s really helpful. Does anyone know if Fiestaware is cadmium free? The sales people tell you it is, but I don’t know how you could get such bright glazes without lead and cadmium.
By kevinandkathleen on Jan 23, 2008 | Reply
Here is another link for a very nice dishes. Far out of my price range, but very well made. The company itself is environmentally minded in every aspect of their business. Certainly some the nicest looking dishes I have seen as well. Lead free, triple fired etc.
http://www.terrakeramik.com/index.php
By harold on Jan 26, 2008 | Reply
Maybe Homer Laughlin, Lenox, and Corning are just more honest than the others… And Dansk happens to be a Lenox brand…
I wonder what Pyrex and Anchor Hocking would say if we called up. { I too use their storage containers. I found some glass lids in a grocery store that fit them– I use those lids in the necrowave and oven. I threw away the plastic knobs, replacing some of the with wood, and leaving some of the lids knobless for long sessions in the oven.}
I wouldn’t go with Ikea– too many suppliers. My ranking would be:
1) Made in the EU. They tend to have stricter standards than the US.
2) Made in the US.
3) I would not use products made in Asia, Mexico,Central America, etc. Give ‘em a few years at least.
H
PS Thanks for all the legwork and info.
By Deby on Feb 2, 2008 | Reply
Now what about PLASTIC…I just found out some information that is terrible …and by the way…HL…Fiestaware IS NOT totally lead free….I have a letter from them stating that….
Anchor Hocking is totally safe have talked to them several times…
ALSO concerned about cookware…crockpots..etc…
LET me know IF you want any more sources for information
Deby
By Mary on Feb 2, 2008 | Reply
Does anyone know anything about Noritake? I was thinking about buying some new. We presently have two sets of their stoneware that was purchased, I believe, over twenty-five years ago. Also does anyone know of a safe crockpot?
Mary
By Ray on Feb 3, 2008 | Reply
Is there any information about porcelain dinnerware? With the higher firing temperatures,it would seem that porcelain would be a better choice.
By Shannon on Feb 4, 2008 | Reply
I just called Mikasa and they said that some of their patterns DO contain lead and I would need to get a pattern # to check for lead in a individual line!
By zakary on Feb 5, 2008 | Reply
Thank you for all your great comments and extra information!
@Andrea: The Lead Plate Results from KUTV is interesting, it sure shines an interesting light on some brands.
I have never heard of the Microwave lead test, but I just ran one of our Pfaltzgraff mugs through the test for fun and it came out cold… interesting, though I’m not sure I would rely solely on that.
@Deby: 0.1 parts-per-million meets the requirements of California Proposition 65 so in theory it is “safer.” It is not lead-free, though if you look at the PDF Andrea pointed us to Corelle results look pretty close to lead-free. Any information you have on slow cookers / crockpots I would definitely be interested in!
@Rita: I’m afraid we must cautiously trust what companies tell us until we find information that proves otherwise. Scary…
@kevinandkathleen: Oh to have a larger disposable income!
@harold: The Pyrex and Anchor Hocking products are great, interestingly Pyrex is made by the same parent company as Corelle, though in theory since they are glass they are lead-free. The European Union definitely seems to have better laws / rules than North America. One of the reasons we liked the Ikea products is because - at least according to them - they make their products to comply with the laws of the strictest country where they sell their products. If this is true is is a great deal for all of the people in less strict countries.
@Mary: I don’t know anything about Noritake, however if I remember correctly there is a lot of concern over old stoneware and porcelain products, this would probably also apply to cold crockpots.
@Ray: From what I have read, porcelain and stoneware should be treated with the same caution when it comes to lead. Not sure how much the firing helps, though Corelle says that lead ‘release is minimized’ due to their high firing temperatures.
@Shannon: That was very helpful of Mikasa eh?
By Christine on Mar 3, 2008 | Reply
I’ve used my 2007 pfaltzgraf dishes for about 6 months. After reading about how dishes that contain lead frequently heat up faster than the food- like my dishes- I bought a Hybrivet 16 unit lead check kit, as recommended by Consumer Reports. My set flunked. “if your swab turns pink and or the confirmation test turns pink to bright red, there are hazardous lead levels. ” It’s a double test for each kit.
symptom- dinnerware heats faster than the food
- dinnerware contains bright colored paints
- dinnerware flunks reliable test
I bought mine at Linens and Things.
it flunked 3/2008
By Linda on Mar 5, 2008 | Reply
My Blue Ikea cereal bowls get hot when in the microwave - does that mean they have lead??
By Kate on Mar 11, 2008 | Reply
I’ve been trying to get information from Royal Doulton on the safety of one of their dinnerware lines for over a week now and they keep delaying a response. In the meantime I’ve looked into switching to glass dinnerware. I found this set that looks promising (www.crateandbarrel.com/family.aspx?c=60&f=26821). Any ideas on if there’s any potential toxin leaching with glass. The company tells me this pattern is lead-free and that it is a pressed glass made of soda lime. Not sure if a borosilicate glass would be better. Any thoughts?
By Debra Lynn Dadd on Mar 21, 2008 | Reply
We’ve been having the same conversation over on my blog.
I wanted to make a few comments.
I think someone commenting here misread what was said about Corelle. It is only the dishes with *decorations* that have lead, the plain white ones do not. This was confirmed by one of my readers, who had here white Corelle dishes tested and they came out having no lead.
I have some other companies listed with lead-free dinnerware and there is a lot of discussion, so if you want more info on this topic, come visit.
Debra Lynn Dadd
www.dld123.com
author, Home Safe Home
author, Really Green
Debra’s List — links to 1000s of green products
Green Living Q&A blog
By P E on Apr 16, 2008 | Reply
The standard of 100 mg/kg is 100 times too much!
By Olga on May 4, 2008 | Reply
I wonder if corningware is the same as Vision ware made in France.
I recently bought 2 sets of pans, but now I am concerned they may contain lead.
I also wonder if Iron cast is safe to use?
Regards
Olga
By Mara Dworsky on May 5, 2008 | Reply
It has been recalled due to lead content.
By lisa esposito on May 6, 2008 | Reply
On 4/28/08 Pfaltzgraft recalled their Villa del Luna pattern due to minimum levels of lead, and cadmium.
This seems contradictory to their finding that they do not use any of these materials.
By Joan Rummell on May 6, 2008 | Reply
lisa, do you have any links or further info. re: the Pfaltzgraff recall?
Thank you.
By Bea on May 11, 2008 | Reply
Hi Deby
I’m doing research for new dishes and want leadfree so would love to have any info you might want to share. Thank you
By Sonja on May 13, 2008 | Reply
I’m flabbergasted. What do manufacturers tell themselves that makes it alright, in their minds, to put toxins in something that they know people will eat off of? I don’t get it. Anyway, I’ve always been in love with Corelle Livingware, you know the dishes that look like solid enamel and don’t break? Please tell me they’re safe.
By Allen Zaretsky on May 14, 2008 | Reply
Dear Bea:
Villa Della Luna ware has been recalled for containing too much lead and cadmium, although Pfaltzgraff has done little or nothing to warn people of this danger. It’s website now says it’s “out of stock”. I just returned six boxes of the stuff, so I know they have some….
By Bea on May 15, 2008 | Reply
Have just talked to a gal a Mikasa and she claimed their stuff is lead free. I’m interested in the chef line, Tyler Florence, has out. It’s white so am hoping but not taking any chances til I find out for sure. This research has been very interesting. A line that Johnson Bros. put out with Emeril I think does have lead. Bea
By Jackie on May 21, 2008 | Reply
from http://www.fda.gov/oc/po/firmrecalls/lifetime04_08.html
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE — April 28, 2008 — Lifetime Brands, Inc., of Garden City, New York, today announced that, as a result of its internal compliance and independent product testing programs, it recently became aware that certain Pfaltzgraff® Villa della Luna® pattern and Nautica J Class® pattern stoneware dinnerware products may exceed the Food and Drug Administration’s (“FDA”) guidance levels for lead and/or cadmium. No illness related to these products has been reported to date.
Specifically, the following products are subject to this recall:
By Ronnie on Jun 19, 2008 | Reply
Slow Cookers…
I have been looking for a slow cooker for quite sometime….But I can’t seem to find one that is not made in China and I’m very leary about products being made there without lead in them.
Do you know of a company that makes slow cookers and are lead free?
Thanks,
Ronnie
By Maria Atwood on Jul 1, 2008 | Reply
This was an EXCELLENT article and great research for all of us. I too have a great need to know what dishes to recommend via my cooking classes and as a Weston A Price Chapter Leader. I have done as much research for lead free crock pots but they all use the California law and say they follow the FDA guidelines….Well, so much for that. I now do all my broth making on top of the stove as crock pots are too hot even on the lowest temperature for making nutrient dense soups/broths.
Thanks so much - Maria www.traditionalcook.com
By Val on Jul 3, 2008 | Reply
www.fda.gov/oc/po/firmrecalls/lifetime04_08.htm
Bea posted on 12/24/07 that she had just purchased the Villa della luna pattern from Pfaltzgraff. Please go to the above site to read that the dinner plate and cereal bowl in this particular pattern along with a Nautica pattern were recalled in April 2008. I just purchased a different pattern by Pfaltzgraff today along with a home testing kit for lead.
By ysabel on Jul 6, 2008 | Reply
I just bought some white porcelain and planning to return them cos I have seen the company’s name in “Import Alert!”(for excessive Lead/Cadmium)here’s the link for your info. http://www.fda.gov/ora/fiars/ora_import_ia5208.html
…Good thing I haven’t started using them..My husband said it’s ok since the ones I bought were not the ones listed there but I told him that better not use them cos I don’t know how they glaze the white porcelain. Then I found this website in search for Lead/Cadmium free products and I learned that Luminarc tempered glass dinner/soup plates and mugs(transparent items) and pyrex glass/ceramics are better…I think and hope!)
By Debra Lynn Dadd on Jul 7, 2008 | Reply
Ysabel ~
I went and took a look at that Import Alert you mentioned. Please note that it is from 2003, which is five years ago. It’s entirely possible that the company has changed that that data is no longer correct. I’m not saying that it has changed and the dinnerware is safe, I just would do more research before deciding that dinnerware is unsafe based on testing a sample of dinnerware five years ago.
Debra Lynn Dadd
www.dld123.com
author, Home Safe Home
author, Really Green
Debra’s List — links to 1000s of green products
Green Living Q&A blog
By Ysabel on Jul 7, 2008 | Reply
Thanks Debra,
I hope they make their products safe now but I have returned them already. We decided to start buying transparent tempered glass since we normally use a dishwasher. Before I learned that “white ceramics/porcelain are safe to use” and now finding out that not all whites are safe …it’s time for me to replace them(they are 5 to 7 yrs. old in our kitchen). I have been using tempered glass(bakeware) for baking/freezing food for many years and I am glad that I can find tempered glass tableware here. But of course I will still continue to do some search since my family and friends always ask me what to buy so I should really be very careful. I already looked at your website and it’s very informative..thanks a lot
By Helen on Jul 8, 2008 | Reply
Re. Ikea dinnerware. Just read your posting about Ikea dinnerware being lead free. I understand that the same stock is sold worldwide throughout their stores. I saw two nice dinnersets at Ikea last year in Australia (one blue, one yellow). Only one of the sets (can’t remember which now) was shown as lead free or lead safe on the product tag. When I enquired regarding this and why the other wasn’t marked lead safe I received a response saying the other did contain lead due to the colour difference. So this is interesting given the response you received. Here in Australia at least I question the companies ability to give accurate product information since once customer service rep assured me their mattresses are produced in Sweden. (Turned out he assumed this because it is a Swedish company). Unfortunately think answers depend on who you speak to when the phone is answered.
By Pat Unice on Jul 21, 2008 | Reply
I was at a Pfaltzgraff store this weekend 7/19/08 and asked about my dinnerware set that I have not seen in stores ..I said I thought it was being discontinued..I found out yes…the dinner plate and soup bowl were recalled..I called Customer Service and spoke to a rep., as I was told my the salesperson that I can bring my dinnerware back, and if I did not have a receipt I would get store credit on the last sale price the item was. Needless to say this is not acceptable, I told her. I have a Pfaltzgraff credit card I took out when I bought the set, and I told them I should of been informed of the recall. I have cancer all ready …my grandchildren eat here all the time, I have my ill brother will me and he is now on thyroid meds., one of the problems that come from it….as he never had any problems before he started to stay with me, as he had lung cancer operation last Dec.,and had every test given. I am so beside myself, I do not know what to do. I have colon cancer…been operated on for it chemo/radiation…in the past years. Now this to worry about. I told them I have lost faith in their product and would not accept a credit from the store. She said that they have my name on file now and I told her I would get back to her when I and think clearly, as I just found out this week. I think the US has to stop letting products be made over seas where there is no control on the manufacture of the products that I sold in this country.
When I spoke to her she could not say what was the problem, paint, dyes, pottery…they do not let customrer service know all, just the higher ups who make the big bucks, and then let the poor customer reps., get all the bad feedback.
By Steph on Jul 29, 2008 | Reply
Hi, I just checked with this company (local to me) and Michelle at Fire and Light said that there is NO LEAD in this beautiful made-in-the-USA-from-recycled-glass glassware. It truly is spectacular!
http://www.fireandlight.com/06contact.html
By Donna on Aug 3, 2008 | Reply
Pat, What Pfaltzgraff pattern did you have? I thought Pfaltzgraff claimed to be lead free? What store were you at? Please respond. Thank you.
By Pell Face on Aug 5, 2008 | Reply
Very clear reasoning. I just read though that with the tests done by Kenyon consulting and Kutv that there is lead in all the countries.
By Melissa on Aug 21, 2008 | Reply
Ok, I really don’t know what information you can rely on anymore. I read that all glassware/glass dinnerware is lead free. But corelle has a glass dinnerware that they say is layered in their ‘glass glaze’. Someone also said they claimed lead in everything they made. Does this mean that even glass can have lead too? Or did they say that about their traditional stoneware dinnerware lines???
I want to replace all of my dishes to glass but am just wanting to make sure that glass is completely safe. Does any have more info on glass dinnerware? And corelle glass dinnerware?
By Linda on Aug 24, 2008 | Reply
I am looking at a set of dishes by Nina Campbell @ Stein Mart but concerned of lead, they are made in China. Does anyone have any info on them Also does Corell plates from wal-mart have lead. I missed that one
By Linda on Aug 24, 2008 | Reply
I’m looking for any info on the Nina Campbell dinnerware @ Stein Mart. Concerned because they are made in China. Also would like info on corelle ware dishes that are mellamine from Wal Mart. Would also like to know if they have lead. Do dishes that are microwave and dishwasher safe have lead in them.
By Charlene on Sep 1, 2008 | Reply
I just recently purchased the Gibson Rave Red Square 16 piece dinnerware set at walmart I am concerned that maybe these dishes have been recalled. Does anyone have any info on these dishes. Thanks
By Stephanie on Sep 22, 2008 | Reply
Responding to “By Melissa on Aug 21, 2008″ Reply
Ok, I really don’t know what information you can rely on anymore. I read that all glassware/glass dinnerware is lead free. But corelle has a glass dinnerware that they say is layered in their ‘glass glaze’. Someone also said they claimed lead in everything they made. Does this mean that even glass can have lead too? Or did they say that about their traditional stoneware dinnerware lines???
I want to replace all of my dishes to glass but am just wanting to make sure that glass is completely safe. Does any have more info on glass dinnerware? And corelle glass dinnerware?
Someone mentioned earlier that Corelle has 1/10 of 1 part per million in all of their dishes, according to a customer rep. It does seem possible that there are glazes in the glassware. But they do apparently meet the CA standards. I’m trying to decide if the CA standards are good enough or if I want to go with Pfaltzgraff.
By Pat on Sep 27, 2008 | Reply
I was at a store, in Ct….outlet one near Old Saybrook. I have now recieved new plates, and I did not have to pay anything, which I would not…. I am going to keep e-mailing their customrer service as I feel I should get some of type of explanation, and compensation, which I have not recieved..the pattern is Villa della Luna..the dinner plates and the soup bowls…
Have you had a problem…the reason why this is late…is that I just went on the web-site…I did not get a e-mail…
Pat
By Sheila on Sep 29, 2008 | Reply
Just searching for more on lead in dishes I happened upon this web site.
I just received a response from Noritake to my question regarding lead in my two patterns. They did not respond to the specific question re: these patterns. They gave a broader statement about their dishes. I am not convinced that I am safe using these dishes.
There response:
Thank you for your inquiry.
Since Prop. 65 did not become into effect until 1993, we do not have lead
levels on our older dinnerware. However, prior to 1993 all dinnerware was
checked by the FDA before entering the US.
The Coalition for Safe Ceramicware recommends using a laboratory service
rather than a home test kit. This kind of measurement typically requires
very sophisticated equipment for reliable test results. Your local health
department should be able to provide the name and number of a lead-testing
lab near you.
The following is our company letter regarding the lead in dinnerware and
Proposition 65.
You may recently have become concerned about media reports concerning lead
in ceramic tableware. A very tiny amount of the lead contained in ceramic
tableware may release into certain foods or beverages. Noritake believes
that all of its ceramic tableware is safe for use by the consumer. Not only
does all Noritake fine china and ceramic ware meet all current lead release
levels applicable nationwide published by the U.S. Food and Drug
Administration (FDA), but Noritake products also meet the international
standards governing lead release issued by the International Standards
Organization (ISO).
Notwithstanding the foregoing, Proposition 65, applicable in California
only, mandates that a warning be given whenever a product exposes a consumer
to more than 0.5 micrograms. This amounts to one-half of one one-millionth
of a gram of lead per day. Proposition 65, which is California law,
recognizes that exposure to lead 1,000 times this 0.5 microgram level has no
observable effect on the consumer.
Noritake tableware is properly fired through a carefully monitored
manufacturing process. Noritake is proud to state that its products are
manufactured under carefully controlled conditions, and with utmost care
that is designed to produce an appealing, durable and safe product.
Noritake success in producing high quality, safe ceramic ware is well
recognized by the FDA, which samples and tests all ceramic tableware that is
sold in the United States. All of Noritake’s products meet published FDA
standards.
As a company that cares about the health and safety of its customers and who
wants them to have all the information they need to make intelligent
purchases, and is in compliance with the California law, Noritake has joined
most of the world’s leading and reputable companies who sell ceramic ware in
the state of California to advise the citizens of that state, through
placarding at retail stores, that its products do contain some lead. As far
as Noritake is aware, it is in full compliance with all state laws
regulating the lead content of ceramic tableware.
Noritake is working around the clock; hand-in-hand with other ceramic ware
makes worldwide, to develop the technology that will eventually result in
ceramic tableware that is lead-free. In the interim, Noritake wants its
customers to know its products are safe.
Finally, Noritake offers some helpful general suggestion below to be borne
in mind to ensure consumer safety when using ceramic tableware.
- Avoid using handmade of homemade “craft ware” for food or beverages;
- Look for and follow label directions on ornamental ware that states “Not
for Food Use — For Decorative Purposes Only.”
- Do not store food or beverages in vessels that appear to be poorly
manufactured, chipped or unsanitary.
- Be alert to conditions and patterns of use that can increase exposure to
lead or other undesirable elements. Consider that acidic foods, high
temperatures and increased time of food contact can increase the lead
release levels particularly in the case of improperly fired ceramics.
Sincerely,
Noritake Service Center
By FSNOW on Oct 23, 2008 | Reply
Donna, I also bought the Pfaltgraff “Villa Del Luna” 5 piece setting for eight this past Christmas. A few months ago I received a warning from Amazon.com to get in tough with the Pfaltgraff co because of a recall. The rep told me that the dinner plates and soup bowls were testing positive for lead and was to be returned immediately. I asked her if any of the other pieces were involved and she assured me that they were not. I received credit which I use to order plates and bowls from another pattern that would match what I still had. Last night I was warming up a hot dog for one minute on the small saucer that was part of the original order; when I reached for the plate, it was so hot that it singed my thumb and forefinger. Natually I dropped it on the floor and it broke in about 20 pieces, all of which were making popping and sizzeling noices and grey smoke was coming off each piece, also the hot dog was burnt where it was touching the saucer. I have worked in ceramics for many yeas and this is NOT normal for pure ceramic. Right now I am trying to find where I need to report this to and have the rest of the set tested.
By critter nanny on Nov 6, 2008 | Reply
I recently received a couple of pieces of Corning Visions cookware that I ordered from a replacement service. The invoice was stamped with the California Prop 65 warning as to lead content. Does anyone have any reliable info on the lead/arsenic/or any other carcinogen content of Corning Visions cookware?
By Judy on Nov 25, 2008 | Reply
I would like to know why Mellisa dishes were discontinued. Ihave been using these dishes for a couple years. The dinner plates and the salad plates are turning real black in the center. I also noticed under the cabinet where they are kept, there is a lot of black, witch looks like lead. Is this why they were discontinued? What can be done about this?
By kellyn on Dec 6, 2008 | Reply
I think you misread that test data. Corelle was one of the dinnerware tested that did the best for no lead. Please review that information again.
By ysabel on Dec 13, 2008 | Reply
Hi Melissa;
Here are the answers/explanations I’ve got from Luminarc when I asked about their glassware(specially the transparent tempered glass):
1. “After checking with our Quality dept, here are the information we can provide you.
Legally speaking, decorated or blank porcelain items can content lead and cadmium.
But, on the other side, they cannot release high level of lead and cadmium.
This point is very important and strictly controlled and the whole of our Foodservice pocelain collections respect these health and safety regulations.
We hope this answers to your request and remain at your disposal for any further information.”
2. “Regarding glassware, only crystal items contain lead because this is the condition for the glass to be qualified as “crystal” (24% of lead in the glass minimum). Under this
level, the glass cannot be considered as crystal. You can recognize the sound of crystal when slightly shocking the glass.
So regarding your request and for a daily use, you can choose your new tableware collection among our LUMINARC dinnerware and drinkware collections without any
problem.
For your information, we have also recently developed a new material called KWARX. This very ecological material was specially created for some of our oenological
collections such as OPEN UP, Oenologue etc…commercialized under CHEF & SOMMELIER brand. This material is totally free of lead and 30% more resistant than a classical
glass.”
By Alex on Dec 28, 2008 | Reply
I read this blog while drinking out of my plain white Corelle cup. How confusing. The above comment says even undecorated white dishes can have lead, while other previous comments say plain white is safe.
I also look at this last comment that says crystal has 24% lead so if it is not crystal it is safe??? What a joke-what if it 23% lead? So do we need to worry about lead in glass too?
Why is it so hard to avoid poisoning ourselves? And how shameful that Europe has higher standards then our own country.
By kay on Jan 4, 2009 | Reply
I have a set of Johnson brothers Hearts and Flowers stoneware (”graniteware”) I was planning on using. It was made in England and decades ago. I know they joined with Wedgewood awhile back and today their patterns are no longer being produced. I wrote Wedgewood in hopes of finding out if there was lead used in the making of this pattern. I haven’t heard anything as of yet. Does anyone know anything about lead content in colored ironware or graniteware? Are the home lead test reliable? Thanks! By the way, I noticed the California Prop 65 coming up on the Amazon website this month everytime I went to put Spode Christmas tree pattern dishes in my cart. That prompted me to do some research on any dinnerware before buying.
By Harold on Jan 5, 2009 | Reply
Rather than ask about every single pattern made by every single manufacture, I think that by now we have enough information to know that the safest thing to do is to avoid standard stoneware and porcelain, and use undecorated glass as much as possible.
Not the most attractive dinnerware, I know, but glazes just aren’t safe.
So I’m a Corelle/Anchor Hocking/Pyrex guy now. With no decorations.
By Harold on Jan 5, 2009 | Reply
In keeping with my last post, let’s re-phrase the slow-cooker question now:
Since stoneware isn’t safe, does anyone know of a slow-cooker with a glass cook-pot? Or has anyone found a glass container that fits in a slow-cooker? If so, what brand of cooker, and what brand of glass pot?
By Sherry on Jan 6, 2009 | Reply
Does anyone have any experience with Dansk dinnerware made in Thailand? The sets we have came from Bed Bath and Beyond. When microwaving food on either the large or smaller plates, some of the plates will heat up very hot while the food stays cool and other plates in the set work fine. Go figure. I’m not sure what it means. There’s been no crazing in the glaze so it leads me to believe there’s lead somewhere in the plate. Why with the same food on different plates the result is different I’m not sure. I’m going to follow-up with Dansk about it but would appreciate any insight from those of you who’ve researched this further.
By Harold on Jan 6, 2009 | Reply
Sherry, read my posts from 1/5…
No good news, IMO.
H
By Sherry on Jan 6, 2009 | Reply
Yes, I think that’s where I’m going to do next as well — go glass. But, I want to see if Dansk will refund my money. This product is useless and dangerous. We’ll see and I’ll let everyone know.
By Harold on Jan 6, 2009 | Reply
Someone mentioned some really nice glass earlier — it’s in this thread somewhere. A bit pricey, if I recall, but what isn’t? If I could see it in person, I’d sure like to upgrade from this Corelle.
H
By bj on Jan 7, 2009 | Reply
Hi, Since it has been so long since this post, i don’t know if you will ever get or see this. But in researching what slow cooker to get, i came up on the site page that had your post about the villa de luna dinnerware. I did a search on that, as i thought i might want to get it.. but was immediately shocked to see the following: http://www.fda.gov/oc/po/firmrecalls/lifetime04_08.html
Since the FDA is in cahoots with monsanto and pharmaceutical companies to make us dependent on drugs and shorten our life spans… it must be really bad when they have to recall a product, to show us that they are on top of things. Please be advised about your dinnerware.
By KD on Jan 7, 2009 | Reply
Does anyone have any information on the lead content of Tienshan Dinnerware
By Harold on Jan 7, 2009 | Reply
Once again, see my posts from 1/5. That’s my opinion.
H
By kay on Jan 11, 2009 | Reply
I believe Sango dinnerware is supposed to be lead free. I am researching it now.
By Harold on Jan 11, 2009 | Reply
What it boils down to is that some manufacturers say that their products are lead-free because they meet FDA guidelines. They can legally get away with saying that.
Other, more honest manufacturers say that no, their products are not lead-free.
Of course, the market punishes the manufacturers that are more honest, and rewards those that are less honest.
Harold
By Amanda Greene on Jan 17, 2009 | Reply
Excellent post, and I toss herein a few (disturbing) tidbits I turned up in my EIGHT hour long, ultimately fruitless, webquest for non-toxic dinnerware:
http://www.productsthathurt.com/blog/200805281757/lifetime-brands-recalls-pfaltzgraff-nautica-j-class-dinnerware-products-due-to-lead-cadmium-poisoning-risk.php
http://www.kutv.com/sites/kutv/content/documents/lead-plates-results.pdf
Goes to show, whatever the company PR line is (Pfaltzgraff & Waeschenbach, e.g., made a big fuss about being lead-free), ultimately, it’s all just a big gamble. Much as it pains me, I’ve decided to go with an excruciatingly utilitarian-looking set of stainless steel dinnerware. Ugly, but at least I can be _certain_ it won’t poison us.
By iikomi on Jan 17, 2009 | Reply
I called the EPA & they told me that every manfacturer MUST by law give you a copy of their M.S.D.S. sheet (MATERIALS SAFETY DATA SHEET) telling you what materials are used in their any product. Also check the web for HOME LEAD TEST kits - to be used on dinnerware not just paint, Maybe some exist for OTHER heavy metals. The health dept can check for lead too
By Connie on Jan 20, 2009 | Reply
Oh my gosh thank you for all your information guys. Well, we are doing the same thing everyone else seems to be doing. I have a set stamped Covington The Covington Edition Stoneware Japan/ Floral Expessions Stoneware Japan. But am going for the all glass from now on. Will watch for any update you have on the crock pots.
Thanks again.
Connie
By Jenna on Feb 16, 2009 | Reply
Hi everyone,
This is a great conversation. So glad I found it! I was just given multiple peices of Corningware. From what I just read of the postings, it looks like I should be fine with it?
Jenna
By Tania on Feb 18, 2009 | Reply
No one has mentioned Emile Henry dinnerware.
Thanks to everyone for the posts on this topic; I’ve been on a quest for attractive lead-free dinnerware and found a claim on Emile Henry’s website that their products are lead-free and cadmium-free. Here is their website: www.emilehenryusa.com
I just ordered some lovely sky blue plates and bowls (sets of four of each) on Amazon for around half off–a great deal. I emailed the company to verify that their glazes contain no lead. I’ll post again when I hear back. I really hope they’re truly lead-free!
–Tania
By Harold on Feb 18, 2009 | Reply
Tania, here,s a copy-and-paste from two of my earlier posts:
“Rather than ask about every single pattern made by every single manufacture, I think that by now we have enough information to know that the safest thing to do is to avoid standard stoneware and porcelain, and use undecorated glass as much as possible.”
“What it boils down to is that some manufacturers say that their products are lead-free because they meet FDA guidelines. They can legally get away with saying that.
Other, more honest manufacturers say that no, their products are not lead-free.”
By Tania on Feb 20, 2009 | Reply
Harold, thank you–I agree that the absolute safest approach would be to use undecorated glass whenever possible. However, I also think that if there is a company that is apparently doing the right thing and not adding lead or cadmium to their dinnerware, we should support them by purchasing their product.
It is true that I can’t be absolutely certain that Emile Henry glazes are lead- and cadmium-free, but I called the U.S. phone number for the company, and an employee read from a company document that said both their clay and glazes are made without lead or cadmium. This is consistent with what their website states. Their products are not made in China, where product control can be an issue, they are made at their factory in France.
I have to admit that I am also motivated by a preference for the look of porcelain and stoneware vs. glass in dinnerware. In any case, I would encourage those searching for lead-free dinnerware to check out their website, www.emilehenryusa.com, which has a U.S. contact number (not the toll-free outlet number, the one below it). Their response was satisfying enough for me, but for others it may make more sense to stick with the glassware we know is safe.
–Tania
By Tamara on Mar 4, 2009 | Reply
I guess I am still confused- So should we believe that Pfaltzgraff is lead-free or just FDA compliant? I am looking at a very colorful stoneware set (pistolet) and dont want to spend the dough if it is going to kill me-lol!
Also can anyone help me on understanding fine china or porcelain and lead issues. I want to buy new not old- but I am hoping to buy a fancy tea set for my daughter…any clues? Pot, sugar, creamer and 4-8 cup and saucer sets- any clue on what manufacturer is safe?
Thanks
Tamara
By Marie on Mar 6, 2009 | Reply
Tania, did you receive your Emile Henry dinnerware? Have you tested it with a lead test kit? I am interested in ordering the blanc (white) color. I was going to buy a Corelle set, but the bowls are much smaller than I prefer. Thank you for your post, and thanks in advance for any additional information.
By gailzr on Mar 12, 2009 | Reply
Help.I am new to this site but am very eager to learn . I have Parkinsons and am convinced there is a connecton beween my getting PD and my exposure to lead based paints in our Bronx apt. and the dishes and pots and pans my mom used. One of my brothers also has PD. Coincidence????I think not. I want new dishes .what should I consider?
By Trae on Apr 1, 2009 | Reply
Does a plate have to get hot in order for the lead to leach? What if you never put them in the microwave or stove and only place hot food on them for eating? Or do they just leach no matter what. I have the Corelle with a decoration on it, so I’m hoping I can keep them.
By LouisM on Apr 28, 2009 | Reply
All profit maximizing corporations are cost minimizing corporations. Materials with lead are cheaper to produce even when factoring in potential recalls and/or lawsuits in a weak civil law, captured regulator market like the US. Corporations are geared for quarterly profits at all costs. That is the system.
When you wave your little American flag and go “Free Markets and capitalism equal freedom and democracy,” you have bought the propaganda myth narrative that is directly responsible for the dangerous products you are complaining about.
Now does anyone know about Graniteware?
By LouisM on Apr 28, 2009 | Reply
My above reply was to Sonja and her “I’m flabbergasted.” comment. We were interested in the safety of Graniteware glaze as it appears to be a good color for solar ovens…
By Holly on May 13, 2009 | Reply
I used to work for World Kitchen, the company that produces Pyrex. You can purchase the lids for your Pyrex seperately. You can find them on the website (www.shopworldkitchen.com) or by calling them.
By Tony on Jun 10, 2009 | Reply
Seriously, thanks for the heads up
By mike on Jun 14, 2009 | Reply
I’ve just purchased some really nice corsica hand painted dinnerware for my girlfriend and I noticed it was made in China.Should I be worried about lead from the paint?
By Harold on Jun 14, 2009 | Reply
I’m a broken record. Read my previous posts.
H
By Claudia Kate on Aug 30, 2009 | Reply
Canada makes the lowest lead content glass pots/ware from my previous web searching.
My vision pyrex is purple in color and accdg to my research any glass with color has lead, i.e., the colors all have lead.
San Francisco Aquarium recently shipped a glass dome all the way from Germany (made to order) because they were the only country that could produce lead-free glass; they were very concerned about the animal/reptile survival!!! interesting huh.
By A Koss on Sep 25, 2009 | Reply
Has anyone had any trouble with lead and mold growing on their dishes. Dishes were mfg by Gibson Overseas.
By A Koss on Sep 25, 2009 | Reply
Has anyone out there had any trouble with lead and mold growing on their dishes. Dishes were mfg by Gibson Overseas. Purchased @ Dillards
By Tal on Oct 3, 2009 | Reply
Be careful with glass if concerned about lead, and if so, avoid lead crystal.
From NY Times in 1991:
“Items made of lead glass may leach lead into the food and beverages contained.[10][11] In a study performed at North Carolina State University[12], the amount of lead migration was measured for port wine stored in lead crystal decanters. After two days, lead levels were 89 µg/L (micrograms per liter). After four months, lead levels were between 2,000 and 5,000 µg/L. White wine doubled its lead content within an hour of storage and tripled it within four hours. Some brandy stored in lead crystal for over five years had lead levels around 20,000 µg/L.[13][14] To put this into perspective, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s lead standard for drinking water is 15 µg/L = 15ppb.[15] Citrus juices and infant formula leach lead from crystal just as effectively as alcoholic beverages. Several companies do make lead crystal baby bottles and it is suspected they may present a health danger to infants.[13]”
link: http://www.nytimes.com/1991/02/19/science/storing-wine-in-crystal-decanters-may-pose-lead-hazard.html
By b.rose on Oct 13, 2009 | Reply
Does anyone have experience or information about ForLife Designs tea and cafe ware, made in China?
I’m just going to carve cups and bowls out of my own mesquite!
By MJ on Nov 9, 2009 | Reply
I did this research, extensively. The only safe bet is clear glassware. The next safest product, which we purchased - is Fiestaware made here, in the U.S.
Whatever the manufactures say about items being lead free is up for grabs, because all that you list above have some or all made in China (which throws the lead regulations for US out the window). Simply look on the back of the plates before you buy. If it’s not made in the US, don’t buy it. (or just buy clear glass)
By MJ on Nov 9, 2009 | Reply
BTW, anything made of clay/ceramic is going to have trace amounts of naturally occurring lead. The issue is the added lead (in glazes or added to the ceramic). This increases the lead to create caution for the consumer.
By sheila on Dec 3, 2009 | Reply
so glad to have found you…thank you…have tried the glass with watr in with empty mugs and plates and these are cheep products they didnt get hot..had a glazelike fiesta made in china by citrus grove did i do something wrong..also have clear glass callalillie from bed and bath but very old with knife scratches on eating side should i replace.they are a tempered glass also thanks
By maria on Dec 10, 2009 | Reply
Lifetime Brand Pfaltzgraff Villa della Luna ands Nautica J Class …
Lifetime Brands, Inc., in conjunction with the FDA, is recalling some of its dinnerware because some of the products may have exceeded the FDA’s guidance …
springfield.injuryboard.com/…/Lifetime-Brand-Pfaltzgraff-Villa-della-Luna-ands-Nautica-J-Class-Dinnerware-Recalled-Due-to-Excessive… - Cached - Similar -
By Terri Lynn on Dec 15, 2009 | Reply
Thanks for all the good info. Harold, don’t get too mad. We ladies like our colored dishes. Not at the expense of the threat of lead, but it’s still sometimes a struggle for us to buy “plain, boring” dishes.
On that note, is anyone familiar with Pfaltzgraff Blue Pointe?
By Marisa on Dec 16, 2009 | Reply
I just found this website article on crockpots. I don’t know if it will make anyone feel any safer, but I feel better.
http://www.terminalverbosity.com/2009/11/09/the-skinny-on-lead-in-crock-pots-it-may-surprise-you/comment-page-1/
By sheila on Dec 16, 2009 | Reply
currently purchased fiestaware by HOmer Laughton in white hping that someone will tell me that they dont have lead issues..they are scratching from flatware does this mean anything..help sheila
By Betty on Jan 13, 2010 | Reply
Claudia,
Where can you get dishes from Canada? Is there a good website?
I have cobalt blue glass dishes from Luminarc and various stoneware and decorated Corelle. So it looks like we need to switch these out.
By Laurie on Jan 23, 2010 | Reply
According to a post at the top of this list, Dansk doesn’t lead. I assume that means no added lead. We just bought Dansk, plain white with a thin blue trim on the edges. According to a letter from Dansk, they also contain no plastic, which means no BPA. We wanted to replace our Corelle because of BPA, which is suppose to be in some dinnerware. I figured it’s in Corelle since its more durable, less breakable. Any thoughts?
By Deborah on Jan 25, 2010 | Reply
I have just discovered that my 2 year old white Providence pattern Pfaltzgraf dinnerware is leaching hazardous amounts of lead. I have been sick for months and have the blood tests to prove it. They offered me new dishes. yeah, right. I improve dimmediatly when I stoopped using them. No idea yet asto the extent of the organ damage. Any one suing them?
By Shawn on Feb 1, 2010 | Reply
I saw some comments thinking glass wouldn’t contain led, but as far as I know glass can contain lead.
I’ve been removing anything that goes into contact with my food that is made in China. Seems even if the manufacturers specify lead shouldn’t be used it doesn’t mean it won’t be. With my luck what remains that is made in USA will have materials bought from China with lead. Maybe testing is the only way to be sure, but then what else would you test for. I think they could and have shown they may use anything if it keeps the cost down even if it’s harmful.
By MARYANN on Feb 2, 2010 | Reply
Has anyone heard of sengWare? It says lead/cadmium free
By gail on Feb 11, 2010 | Reply
WOW, thanks for the test. I was just complaining to Cuisinart about dishes I had bought from them. The mugs got hot and untouchable. I did your little test and they must be pure lead. Thanks I will look for new dishes this weekend.
By Marian on Feb 15, 2010 | Reply
I have the pattern “Gourmet Harvest” by Noritake, which I believe came out in the late 1990’s. Can I assume that this is safe?
By Allyson on Mar 7, 2010 | Reply
I have some old Fiesta dishes from my grandmother. Not sure exactly when they were purchased, but easily 40 years or so ago. I have notices that they are getting black marks on them. I am wondering if they contain lead paint and that’s why they are doing that. Any input? Thank you in advance for your thoughts…..
By Marian on Mar 7, 2010 | Reply
This is an update on my previous (Feb 15) post. I recently ordered some replacements of my Noritake Gourmet Harvest dishes (originally manufactured in the mid- to late 1990’s), and they arrived @ my residence with the California-mandated Proposition 65 warning–that use of the dishes will expose a person to lead . . . back the dishes went, and we are now using some Homer Laughlin dishes, along with some Fiesta Ware. You can check out the webside at http://hlchina.com/
By Wilma on Mar 11, 2010 | Reply
I own some old cornflower design corningware. A few years ago I asked them if it continaed any lead.
They never responded.
Do you know?